Home » Picking the Best Toilet Paper for Sensitive Skin – Reviews and Comparisons!

Picking the Best Toilet Paper for Sensitive Skin – Reviews and Comparisons!

If you buy something through a link in our posts, we may get a small share of the sale.

Last Updated March 24th 2019:  The impact that rough toilet paper can have on your skin and intimate areas is often overlooked when we do our weekly shop. However with so much variety on the market we can end up making the wrong choice.  Are you tired of having to use tissue because tissue is softer than TP?  Well  you don't have to put your septic system at risk using tissue anymore!  Thankfully in this guide we will help you pick the best toilet paper for sensitive skin and  provide you with in-depth reviews of each toilet paper brands.

Sensitive Skin Toilet Paper Comparison Table

Product Name



Learn More

Charmin Ultra Gentle

Using cheaper or less reliable brands can often lead to irritation and damaging the skin. This is unpleasant and very uncomfortable, especially in younger children who have more sensitive skin.  That being said, if you are looking for something to make your bathroom experience a little easier for everyone, take a look at our bathroom air fresheners.

Best Toilet Paper For Sensitive Skin

Allergies to specific ingredients can mean that you need a more specialist toilet paper. If not then the end result is dryness, soreness, red skin or rashes. Studies have even shown that some toilet paper is so rough is can cause micro cuts on the skin, which are painful and uncomfortable.

Thankfully the answer is out there, with companies making ranges of sensitive toilet paper which is the best to deal with the issue. There are a few on the market so we’ve identified our top three for you to choose from.

Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper

Charmin are perhaps the most recognizable name in the toilet paper industry with a presence in most countries. They’ve been operating since 1920, beginning with just a single product. Nowadays they have a wide product range, including sensitive ranges.

Charmin as a company are committed to making the bathroom experience more pleasant. They have created award winning products with recycled papers and made themselves pretty much the most popular choice for toilet paper.

Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper

Charmin’s Ultra Gentle toilet paper has been developed to replace their sensitive toilet paper. It’s been specifically created for those with sensitive skin to give a smooth and easy wipe every time.  This is really as comfortable as tissue!  They come in a variety of sizes, anywhere from 4 rolls up to 24 rolls or larger with their mega roll packs.

Created specially to help those in need, the toilet paper has soothing lotion on every single sheet. This is what makes it so effective and one of the best available. It’s made in 2 ply sheets to be thicker and softer, making wiping easier and the roll longer lasting, while still being septic safe.

charmin toilet paper for sensitive skin

The Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper has been dermatologically tested to give the best possible results. This means you can have confidence that even with sensitive skin you won’t have an unpleasant experience.

Finally the Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper has been tested by plumbers. The toilet roll is clog free and won’t block your toilet, despite being thicker and softer than alternative brands.

Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper Customer Reviews

Customers seem really pleased with the product that Charmin have produced:

“This may sound crazy, but this is my favorite tp! It is very soft but strong enough to get the job done, and it's also safe for septic tanks systems.” - Ted E.

People admire the durability of the toilet roll and how it improves the overall bathroom experience.

The only real criticism of the Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper seems to be that it’s hard to find in a lot of countries. Your best bet is to look online, sites like amazon normally carry a healthy stock.

It is one of the most expensive brands around, but if you suffer with sensitive skin you’ll appreciate the relief is worth the extra cost.

Charmin Ultra Gentle Toilet Paper Reviewed

Charmin are the biggest name in the toilet tissue world and know how to make a really useful product. Charmin’s Ultra Gentle toilet paper has been created with recycled papers with those who suffer from painful wiping in mind. It’s been developed to replace the burning sensation with a cooling and soothing experience. If you have sensitive skin then you should go and buy some today and let the healing begin.

Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper

Alongside the Ultra Gentle range, Charmin have developed their Ultra Soft Toilet Paper. It’s unsurprising that Charmin have 2 of our top 3 spots, simply because they are one of the best toilet paper manufacturers for sensitive skin.

Charmin Ultra Soft toilet paper is made with 2 ply sheets to make it more durable and reduce irritation but it is still as comfortable as tissue! This means you’ll use less than other brands and the rolls will last longer. Available scented or unscented depending on preference and is soft to the touch. This means no soreness or irritation.  Along with this, these are sourced from recycled sources.

The Charmin Ultra Soft toilet paper has won a seal of approval from Good Housekeeping and is one of the most popular toilet papers on the market.

Charmin Ultra Soft toilet roll has been dermatologically tested to make sure it’s gentle on your skin. It’s also been tested by plumbers to make sure it won’t clog your toilet like a tissue might. Charmin products have also been proven to last up to 4x longer than alternative products.

Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper Customer Reviews

Just like their Ultra Gentle range, the Ultra Soft toilet paper is getting positive reviews across the board from their customers:

“These are ultra comfortable and double rolls and best of all they overall work better than any other that we have used: EVER. Some TP is too rough; not theirs. Some TP falls apart before finishing its purpose; not theirs. Some TP is so thick it will not flush; not theirs” - Mandy P.

Some customers have complained that while the toilet paper is as comfortable as they expected, it isn’t as thick as some other brands, and this could be because they are made from recycled thinner materials so the sheets aren't as thick. It’s always worth shopping around, but Charmin do know their stuff when it comes to toilet paper, so don’t be surprised if you end up back where you started.

While being a similar product, the ultra soft toilet paper doesn’t feature the soothing lotion. This can mean less soothing relief, but some users can be allergic to the ingredients so it’s a better option.

The main advantage of these Charmin Ultra Soft Toilet Paper rolls is that it’s more affordable and available pretty much everywhere, and because it's sourced from recycled material it's great for the environment. Charmin know how to make great toilet paper rolls that can deal with sensitive skin, so don’t settle for less and upgrade your toilet roll today.

Cottonelle Gentle Care Toilet Paper

Cottonelle are the American brand, producing toilet paper that is sold worldwide. They believe in making your bathroom experience as comfortable as possible with a range designed for different requirements and budgets.

Cottonelle have a full line of products which are all septic tanks safe (which is a big reason you shouldn't use a tissue while wiping) and more durable than a lot of their competition. They look to add value to the customer with choices that last longer and give more comfort.

Cottonelle Gentle Care toilet papers is made with a clean ripple texture. This is soft but designed to give a thorough clean from even a single wipe. The toilet paper is 1ply sheets rather than 2ply sheets so it’s less thick than the Charmin toilet paper but it should still reduce irritation.

Each sheet of Cottonelle Gentle Care toilet paper contains Aloe and Vitamin E. These are known for their soothing properties and are gentle on sensitive skin. The toilet paper has been dermatologically tested by professionals which along with the aloe and vitamin E, this makes it one of the best choices.

Cottonelle Gentle Care Toilet roll Customer Reviews

Cottonelle users seem impressed by the cooling and soothing result of using their gentle toilet paper:

“I found this, and thought I would give the Aloe a try. It changed my life. I no longer have to deal with the times when I get sensational burning, if I do, I know I can just wipe to bring soothing alleviation” - Denny D.

A criticism some users have made of the product is that the toilet paper is too thin and tears easily:

“ From my experience, This stuff tears real easily. I do not like paper that your tears or your fingers go through as soon as you start to use it. The aloe on this paper just makes it more easily torn.” - Scott F.

Cottonelle have opted for a 1ply toilet paper rolls instead of 2ply rolls, meaning it is thinner than the alternatives. This does mean that it can tear more easily. On the flip side it makes it very gentle and the soothing aloe does a great job of helping to soothe. This just means you may have to be slightly careful when using the product, but it doesn’t seem like it’s an issue for many users.

Cottonelle Gentle Care toilet rolls is one of the most popular toilet paper rolls around because of it’s soothing ingredients and soft touch. It’s long lasting which means more value for the customer and their double roll is perfect for those with families who don’t want to have to replace it so regularly.  Along with this, it is septic system safe so you have no reason to worry!

An affordable and effective product, it’s one of the best choices for those with sensitive skin and you need it in your bathroom!

Choosing the Best Toilet Paper for Your Sensitive Skin

All three of these names are well known by most households around the world. They’ve taken the time to create unique products to help those with sensitive skin, and have made some very useful and soothing toilet paper.  Thankfully with these toilet paper rolls you don't have to worry as much about clogs in your septic.  But if you have been experiencing toilet clogs then you should check out our toilet auger reviews page.

Each of them have made the list because of their soft, durable and long lasting nature. They’re all great choices for those with sensitive skin and available in most places plus through online stores like Amazon.

They are all similar, with just a few distinct differences, so your choice will depend on your preferences when it comes to scent and lotion.

Overall It seems like Charmin are making the best toilet paper rolls for those with sensitive skin, and it’s clearly the most popular choice at the moment. Check out their range today and make the switch to gentle toilet paper if you or your family suffer from sensitive skin.